Markets
    Australia

    Chalmers Rejects Spender's 40% CGT Plan as Australia's Startup Tax Bill Nears Senate Test

    Business groups back a flat discount for all active assets, while the Greens weigh a summer inquiry that could hold up the startup carve-out and venture capital changes.

    Share on X LinkedIn WhatsApp
    Parliament House in Canberra, Australia
    Parliament House in Canberra, where a startup capital gains tax bill faces a Senate test. Photo: Dietmar Rabich via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

    What to know

    • Treasurer Jim Chalmers said on Nov. 17 that Treasury sees Allegra Spender's flat 40% CGT discount for active business assets as more complex and open to integrity problems.
    • Spender's plan would replace Labor's Innovative Business CGT Concession, which keeps a 50% discount only for qualifying innovative companies, and the Parliamentary Budget Office estimated it would raise A$590 million more through 2029-30, according to Startup Daily.
    • The Greens, whose votes Labor needs in the Senate, are considering a summer inquiry into the bill, which also carries R&D tax incentive and venture capital changes.

    SYDNEY

    Australian Treasurer Jim Chalmers has rejected a rival plan to give every active business, not just government-certified "innovative" startups, a 40% capital gains tax discount, setting up a contest in the Senate over how founders, early employees and venture investors will be taxed when they sell shares.

    Speaking at the Australian Securities and Investments Commission's annual forum in Sydney on Tuesday, Nov. 17, Chalmers said Treasury had analyzed the proposal from independent MP Allegra Spender and judged it likely to be more complex. "It could lead to higher taxes on some innovative start-ups," he said, according to The Adviser and Australian Associated Press, adding that the government also saw more integrity issues in the model. He said he had written to Spender setting out those concerns and had not been negotiating with the Greens over her plan.

    The decision matters well beyond Canberra. The rules will set the after-tax return on a successful exit for anyone holding equity in an Australian startup, from founders who started with a nominal cost base to staff paid partly in options and the venture funds that back them.

    What Labor's startup carve-out does

    The fight traces back to Labor's May budget, which replaces the 50% capital gains discount with inflation indexation of an asset's cost base and a minimum 30% tax on gains, for gains accruing from July 1, 2027. Indexation offers little relief to a founder whose shares cost a few dollars a decade earlier. AAP reported in June that the change would roughly double the maximum effective rate on such gains to nearly 47%.

    After a backlash from founders and investors, the government designed the Innovative Business CGT Concession, or IBCC, which keeps the 50% discount for founders, employees and early investors who hold qualifying equity for at least three years, according to Startup Daily. To keep issuing qualifying equity, a company must show each year that innovation accounts for more than half of at least two of three measures: its assets, its workers and its income.

    The concession sits in the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 4) Bill 2026, which Chalmers introduced on Oct. 27. His release said the bill also refocuses the Research and Development Tax Incentive from July 1, 2028, raises thresholds for venture capital incentives from July 1, 2027, and lets venture investors use the IBCC on eligible companies, including where returns come as carried interest. The Department of Industry, Science and Resources is still finalizing safe harbor arrangements on the innovation test, the release said. The bill passed the lower house last month, Startup Daily reported, and now needs crossbench votes in the Senate.

    Spender's flat 40% alternative

    Spender, the member for Wentworth and a cofounder of the Community Strong Australia party, wants to scrap the IBCC and its tests on company age and turnover. In their place she proposes a flat 40% discount on active business assets, including shares and employee options, with a top effective rate of about 28%. Passive assets such as investment property would stay under indexation, and the 30% minimum rate would remain, The Adviser reported.

    The trade-off for startup founders is a smaller discount in exchange for wider and more predictable eligibility. On a A$100,000 gain, a founder who qualifies for Labor's concession would declare A$50,000 as taxable income, compared with A$60,000 under Spender's plan, Startup Daily calculated. Startup Daily's Simon Thomsen estimated in a separate column that on a A$1 million gain, a founder on the top marginal rate would pay about A$47,000 more in tax including the Medicare levy.

    The Parliamentary Budget Office estimated that Spender's plan would raise A$590 million more through 2029-30 than the government's model with the IBCC in place, according to Startup Daily, which noted that the office acknowledged gaps in the data.

    Business groups have lined up behind the idea. The Business Council of Australia, the Council of Small Business Organisations Australia, the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry and the Australian Industry Group all support it, Startup Daily reported, although the Business Council still prefers the Coalition's pledge of full repeal. Opposition Leader Angus Taylor has said the Coalition would oppose the budget tax increases and repeal them if elected, The Adviser reported, while Liberal Senator Andrew Bragg said any tightening of investor tax settings, including Spender's version, was unacceptable, AAP reported.

    The Greens hold the timetable

    With the Coalition opposed, Labor needs the Greens. Greens Treasury spokesman Nick McKim said he had discussed the alternative with Spender, called her proposals "very interesting," and said the party was considering sending the bill to a Senate committee over summer, where her model could be examined, according to The Adviser.

    That would push the startup concession past the government's preferred timetable. The Adviser reported on Nov. 17 that Labor wanted its remaining budget bills through the Senate by the end of the following week, with the new capital gains regime due to start on July 1, 2027. Because the IBCC, the R&D incentive changes and the venture capital measures travel in one bill, a delay to one holds up all three, Startup Daily noted.

    Labor is negotiating with the Greens on a second front: a 30% minimum tax on discretionary trusts, which the Business Council says would cost businesses about A$4 billion in its first year once compliance costs are included, according to AAP. McKim has tied Greens support for that measure to talks on trust deductions.

    For founders weighing a move offshore, the debate has a trans-Tasman edge. University of Melbourne tax expert Miranda Stewart told a Senate inquiry in June that New Zealand has zero capital gains tax, but said evidence suggests most people do not relocate for tax reasons, AAP reported.

    Capital Times has covered how startup investors exit through IPOs and acquisitions and Australia's Division 296 tax on large super balances.

    Parliament is in its final sitting fortnight of the year. Whether the Greens refer the bill to a committee will decide whether startups know their exit tax rules before the new regime takes effect on July 1, 2027.

    Sources

    1. The Adviser: Greens weigh CGT roadblock as Chalmers rejects rival plan (Nov. 17, 2026)
    2. Australian Associated Press (via The Senior): Labor clings to tax tweaks amid possible derailment (Nov. 17, 2026)
    3. Startup Daily: Business gets behind Allegra Spender's 40% CGT plan as Labor puts their trusts in Greens votes (Nov. 17, 2026)
    4. Startup Daily: The chef takes risks too; why startups should back Spender on CGT (Nov. 17, 2026)
    5. Startup Daily: Independent MP Allegra Spender fights the government's startup CGT changes in Parliament with a simpler Plan B (Oct. 28, 2026)
    6. Treasurer of Australia (media release): Tax reforms to support innovation and investment (Oct. 27, 2026)
    7. Startup Daily (Australian Associated Press): Labor downplays trust changes as business warns of a $4 billion hit in a year (Nov. 18, 2026)
    8. The Canberra Times (Australian Associated Press): 'Missed opportunity': tax findings land as talks go on (June 19, 2026)
    9. Shepparton News (Australian Associated Press): Fight and flight: tax inquiry fuming just a smokescreen (June 16, 2026)

    Capital Times Staff

    Capital Times newsroom, Hong Kong, Singapore and Jakarta

    Capital Times covers markets, business and economies across Asia.

    newsroom@capitaltimes.asia

    Our standards: Capital Times reports under the principles set out in our Editorial Standards and Ethics Policy. Spotted an error? Report it to our editors.

    Markets Data

    Hong Kong ClosedShanghai ClosedTokyo ClosedSeoul ClosedSingapore ClosedJakarta ClosedSydney ClosedMumbai Closed