Markets
    Reserve Bank of Australia

    RBA Minutes Show 3 Dissenters Feared a 'Sharper Downturn' as Bullock Says Oil Is Not the Only Cause

    Six board members judged a 4.60% cash rate was not clearly enough to tame inflation. The governor told a Sydney forum that inflation was a problem before the oil shock, while markets bet rates have peaked.

    Share on X LinkedIn WhatsApp
    Office towers of Sydney's central business district rising behind Circular Quay
    Sydney's central business district from Circular Quay. Photo: -wuppertaler via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

    What to know

    • Minutes released Tuesday show six RBA board members judged a 4.60% cash rate was not clearly sufficient to return inflation to target, given a likely higher neutral rate.
    • The three members who voted to hold warned the economy might be near the point of entering a materially sharper downturn, with costs for jobs, and wanted more time to judge the year's 100 basis points of tightening.
    • Governor Michele Bullock told the ASIC Forum that inflation was above target before the Middle East conflict lifted oil prices, and named AI-driven demand, oil and inflation expectations as upside risks, according to ABC News.

    SYDNEY

    The Reserve Bank of Australia's board raised its cash rate to 4.85% this month because a majority judged that the previous setting of 4.60% was not clearly enough to bring inflation back to target, while the three members who voted against warned the economy might be close to a much sharper slowdown, according to minutes of the Nov. 2-3 meeting published on Tuesday morning.

    The record gives the fullest account yet of the 6-3 split behind the RBA's fifth increase this year, which took the cash rate to an 18-year high, according to Australian Associated Press. It also stops short of promising more. All nine members agreed to stay attentive to the data and said policy was well placed to respond to developments, wording that leaves the next meeting, on Dec. 7-8, open in both directions.

    Governor Michele Bullock, speaking at the Australian Securities and Investments Commission's annual forum in Sydney on Tuesday morning, set out three risks that could push inflation higher still, according to ABC News. Our preview of Tuesday's events has the background to the vote and the RBA's speaking calendar.

    Why six members wanted to move now

    The majority's case rested on a worse inflation outlook and a sense that policy was not as tight as it looked. Staff now expect headline and underlying inflation to stay above 3% until late 2027 and to reach the 2.5% midpoint of the target band only in mid-2028, the minutes said, and even that path assumes the additional tightening that markets had priced.

    Members cited three signs that domestic capacity, not just imported fuel costs, was driving prices: a rise in market services inflation in the September quarter, persistently strong growth in unit labour costs, and reports of broad-based cost pressures from the bank's business liaison program. Staff also raised their estimate of the unemployment rate consistent with stable inflation, which implies the labour market was tighter in early 2026 than previously thought.

    Oil is the other pressure point. Crude and refined fuel prices had risen 20% to 25% since August amid the Middle East conflict, the minutes said. The forecasts assume oil falls by about US$30 a barrel over two years, which members noted would require some resolution of the conflict, and that around two-thirds of the extra cost is passed on to consumers. Staff also warned that headline inflation would be significantly higher in October than in September as household subsidies from a year earlier drop out of the annual calculation.

    A further thread concerns the neutral interest rate. Members said estimates of neutral in Australia and abroad appear to have drifted higher, reflecting large fiscal deficits in major economies and heavy investment tied to artificial intelligence. Part of the 100 basis points of tightening delivered earlier this year may simply have removed stimulus left over from late 2025, they said. Data center developers alone had raised debt equal to at least one-fifth of this year's increase in Australian business debt, the minutes said.

    The six concluded that the risk of leaving policy too loose, and letting medium-term inflation expectations rise, outweighed the risk of tightening too far.

    The minority's warning

    The three dissenters argued that, having raised rates in September, the board should give the full 100 basis points more time to work. They placed less weight on upside inflation risks and more on growth, and warned that the economy "might be near the point of entering a materially sharper downturn," with costs for jobs, the minutes said. Reuters, in a report carried by ABC News, also highlighted that warning, linking it to rising unemployment and falling home prices.

    The case for holding, which the minority found stronger, cited a half-point rise in the unemployment rate over the six months before the meeting, a housing downturn that could hit activity harder than the historical average, and signs that sentiment toward data center construction could prove fragile. Some members also noted that the monthly pace of market services inflation slowed through the quarter and that wage growth had held steady, while financial market measures of inflation expectations remain well anchored.

    The minutes showed how far market pricing had moved before the vote. Overnight indexed swaps implied an 85% chance of a hike at the meeting and a cash rate about 35 basis points higher by mid-2027, and almost all economists tracked by staff expected an increase.

    Bullock: the risks are still to the upside

    At the ASIC Forum, Bullock named AI and data center spending as one of three upside risks, saying the boom was adding to demand at a time when the economy had little room to absorb it, according to ABC News. The second was that oil prices might not ease as the forecasts assume. The third was inflation expectations, with liaison contacts suggesting some businesses had begun to treat 3% to 3.5% inflation as normal, she said. She listed falling home prices and broad uncertainty as downside risks.

    She also rejected the idea that the year's increases were simply a reaction to fuel costs. Inflation was above target and rates were already rising before the conflict began, she said, according to AAP. "We can't offset the oil price rises," she told the forum, adding that rates can instead cool excess demand. Headline inflation stands at 4.3%, against the 2% to 3% target, AAP reported.

    What markets expect for December

    Traders are not betting on a follow-up. Futures price only an 8% chance of a hike in December and around 31% by February, with the cash rate peaking near 4.92%, according to Billy Leung, senior investment strategist at Global X ETFs, in comments carried by ABC News. Reuters reported about 22 basis points of easing priced by the end of 2027, with unemployment at a five-year high of 4.7%.

    Abhijit Surya, senior Asia-Pacific economist at Capital Economics, said in comments carried by ABC News that the minutes showed the decision was not clear-cut and did not signal further tightening. He expects the next move to be a cut, most likely in the fourth quarter of 2027.

    The release landed on a weak day for Australian assets. The S&P/ASX 200 closed down 1.8% at 8,883 points for a 2.7% drop over five sessions, while the Australian dollar edged up 0.2% to 67.46 U.S. cents, according to ABC News. For earlier market reaction to the decision itself, see our report on Australian bond yields after the split vote.

    The board's next meeting is scheduled for Dec. 7-8, according to ABC News; AAP noted it will be the last of the year.

    Sources

    1. Reserve Bank of Australia: Minutes of the Monetary Policy Board Meeting, Sydney, 2 and 3 November 2026 (Nov. 17, 2026)
    2. Australian Associated Press: 'Made it worse': Iran war not only cause of rate rises (Nov. 17, 2026)
    3. ABC News: Markets live updates, Tuesday 17 November (RBA minutes, Bullock at ASIC Forum) (Nov. 17, 2026)

    Capital Times Staff

    Capital Times newsroom, Hong Kong, Singapore and Jakarta

    Capital Times covers markets, business and economies across Asia.

    newsroom@capitaltimes.asia

    Our standards: Capital Times reports under the principles set out in our Editorial Standards and Ethics Policy. Spotted an error? Report it to our editors.

    Markets Data

    Hong Kong OpenShanghai OpenTokyo OpenSeoul OpenSingapore OpenJakarta LunchSydney ClosedMumbai Open