Markets
    Coal

    Chinese Buyers Push Back on Indonesian Coal Waivers as 2027 Contract Talks Stall

    Indonesian miners want clauses that excuse missed deliveries if Jakarta cuts quotas. Chinese buyers, already hit by a near 10% drop in shipments this year, are refusing.

    Share on X LinkedIn WhatsApp
    Barges loaded with coal moored along a canal
    Barges loaded with coal Photo: Michaela Pereckas via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

    What to know

    • Some Indonesian coal producers are seeking waiver clauses in 2027 contracts that would excuse missed deliveries if Jakarta cuts output quotas or delays export approvals, and Chinese buyers are resisting, Bloomberg reported.
    • Indonesian coal exports to China fell almost 10% in the first 10 months of 2026 from a year earlier, according to Kpler data cited by Bloomberg.
    • Indonesia's energy ministry expects 2026 output of about 720 million tons, down from about 817 million tons in 2025, and CRU Group sees about 700 million tons next year.

    JAKARTA

    Chinese coal buyers are refusing to sign 2027 supply contracts that would let Indonesian miners skip deliveries whenever Jakarta cuts production quotas or holds up export approvals, a standoff that is slowing the annual round of deals between the world's biggest thermal coal exporter and its biggest customer.

    Some Indonesian producers want waiver clauses that would release them from contracted volumes in those cases, Bloomberg reported last week, citing people familiar with the talks. Chinese buyers are reluctant, the report said, especially after policy changes in Jakarta disrupted deliveries this year. Shanghai Metals Market (SMM), a Chinese commodity data provider, reported the same resistance on Nov. 11 and said some Chinese buyers had reportedly delayed annual negotiations while they wait for clarity on Indonesia's production target and mine-level quotas.

    For utilities and traders in China, and for coal producers listed in Jakarta, Sydney and Hong Kong, the dispute goes to the heart of how seaborne coal is priced next year. Term contracts set the base load of Indonesian supply into China. If they arrive late or with broad escape clauses, more buying shifts to the spot market, and some of it may move to other suppliers.

    Who carries the policy risk

    The fight is about which side absorbs the cost of Indonesian government decisions. Jakarta has tightened its grip on coal over the past year. Miners must meet domestic supply obligations before selling abroad, and the government is routing exports through state-controlled channels to improve price transparency and curb under-invoicing, according to the Bloomberg report.

    Output is now set under the RKAB system, the annual work plan and budget each miner must have approved before it can dig. Indonesia's energy ministry cut the validity of those plans from three years to one under a regulation that took effect in October 2025, and it has confirmed that 2027 plans will also be approved annually, SxCoal reported. Companies must file their applications for the following year between Oct. 1 and Nov. 15, according to the same report, which means the 2027 window was due to close on Sunday.

    That timetable is what worries buyers. Further delays could mean producers start the new year without knowing how much coal they are allowed to mine, Bloomberg said. Slow approvals early this year forced the ministry to let companies mine up to 25% of their planned annual output until March 31 while applications were assessed, SxCoal reported. The Indonesian Mining Experts Association has argued that restoring three-year plans is the key to ending approval delays, according to the same report.

    Exports to China slip

    The effect is already visible in trade data. Indonesian coal exports to China fell almost 10% in the first 10 months of the year from a year earlier, according to Kpler data cited by Bloomberg.

    The drop came even though production has run well above the government's original plan. Jakarta first set 2026 output at about 600 million tons, far below the roughly 817.5 million tons mined in 2025, Petromindo reported in June. Energy and Mineral Resources Minister Bahlil Lahadalia later said the government would allow a "measured relaxation" of quotas after prices rose with tensions in the Middle East.

    By September the ministry expected about 720 million tons for the full year. Tri Winarno, its director general of minerals and coal, said 423 million tons had been mined through July, about 60 million tons a month, according to Indonesia Business Post. Of that, about 270 million tons were exported and 113.8 million tons sold at home, with the rest going into stockpiles. China and India remain the main export markets, he said.

    Lower volumes have not hurt the state's take. Non-tax revenue from coal rose to 66 trillion rupiah in the first eight months of 2026 from 59 trillion rupiah a year earlier, the ministry said, according to the same report. Tri Winarno put it simply: monthly output fell by 8 million tons while revenue rose by 7 trillion rupiah.

    Prices have held up. Indonesia's benchmark HBA price for high-energy 6,322 kcal coal was set at $125.60 a ton for the first half of November, down $1.21 from late October, Mysteel reported.

    Readers can find more detail in our earlier report on Indonesia's plan to drop smelter power plants from the coal domestic market obligation.

    Supply squeeze unlikely, but uncertainty grows

    Analysts do not expect a collapse in Indonesian shipments. Glen Kurokawa, an analyst at CRU Group, told Bloomberg that Indonesia will probably keep output at about 700 million tons next year, so an export squeeze is unlikely.

    The risk falls more on individual contracts than on total supply. Delayed deals and broad waivers could leave Chinese buyers unsure whether nominated cargoes will actually arrive, raising their exposure to swings in spot prices, the Bloomberg report said. That could steer some demand toward Indonesia's rivals, including Australia and Mongolia.

    For Indonesian producers, the waiver push reflects a real bind. A miner that signs for a fixed volume in December has no guarantee its RKAB will allow it to produce that much, or that export approvals will come on time. Buyers in China, which have their own winter supply to manage, see little reason to take that risk off the miners' hands.

    The next markers are Indonesia's decision on the national 2027 production target and the allocation of individual quotas, along with the HBA benchmark for the second half of November.

    Sources

    1. Bloomberg via The Edge Malaysia: Chinese coal buyers balk at Indonesian miners' contract demands (Nov. 10, 2026)
    2. Shanghai Metals Market (SMM): Chinese Buyers Reject Waiver Clauses in Indonesian Coal Supply Contracts for 2027 (Nov. 11, 2026)
    3. Indonesia Business Post: Energy Ministry targets 720MT coal production by year-end 2026 (Sept. 10, 2026)
    4. Petromindo: Indonesia's coal quota review could lift output, though below last year's peak (June 10, 2026)
    5. SxCoal: Indonesia keeps annual RKAB reporting for coal, minerals through 2027
    6. Mysteel: Indonesia raises HBA for lower-CV thermal coals for H1 Nov, high-CV grade slips (Nov. 2, 2026)

    Capital Times Staff

    Capital Times newsroom, Hong Kong, Singapore and Jakarta

    Capital Times covers markets, business and economies across Asia.

    newsroom@capitaltimes.asia

    Our standards: Capital Times reports under the principles set out in our Editorial Standards and Ethics Policy. Spotted an error? Report it to our editors.

    Markets Data

    Hong Kong ClosedShanghai ClosedTokyo ClosedSeoul ClosedSingapore ClosedJakarta ClosedSydney OpenMumbai Closed