Markets
    AI Memory

    U.S. Judge Lets DRAM Price-Fixing Suit Against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron Proceed

    A federal court in California found the claims that the three memory makers used the AI-driven shift to high-bandwidth memory to squeeze conventional DRAM supply plausible enough to go forward.

    Share on X LinkedIn WhatsApp
    A DRAM memory module with its chips visible
    A DRAM memory module. Photo: Mister rf via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

    What to know

    • Judge Noël Wise of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California on Nov. 14 denied a motion by Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron to dismiss a proposed DRAM price-fixing class action, court records show.
    • The 17 plaintiffs allege coordinated supply cuts, including a pivot to high-bandwidth memory, that helped push DRAM prices up as much as 500% in a year.
    • The three companies must respond to the complaint by Dec. 7, and an initial case management conference is set for January 2027.

    HONG KONG

    A U.S. federal judge on Friday, Nov. 14, refused to throw out a proposed class action accusing Samsung Electronics, SK Hynix and Micron Technology of colluding to restrict supply of DRAM, the memory chips whose prices have soared as the three companies poured capacity into high-bandwidth memory for AI servers.

    Judge Noël Wise of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California signed the order denying the companies' motion to dismiss on Nov. 14, the court docket shows. She found the plaintiffs' new allegations enough to support a plausible inference of collusion, according to Tom's Hardware, which reported the ruling on Sunday, and the Taiwanese market research firm TrendForce, which followed on Monday. The decision is not a finding of wrongdoing. It lets the case move into a phase where the companies could be asked to hand over internal documents on how they decided to allocate supply.

    For investors in Seoul and Tokyo, the case goes to the heart of the strategy behind the memory boom. Memory makers have steered production toward HBM sold under long-term contracts to AI chip customers while conventional DRAM stayed scarce, and SK Hynix has reported record profits. Capital Times has covered SK Hynix's record quarterly profit and the rise in DRAM contract prices in recent weeks.

    What the plaintiffs say Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron did

    The suit, Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics, was filed on June 25 by 17 plaintiffs, 14 individuals and three small PC businesses, Tom's Hardware reported at the time. It invokes Section 1 of the Sherman Act, seeks class status, an injunction and treble damages, and says the three companies together hold around 90% of the global DRAM market.

    The plaintiffs point to four parallel moves, according to Tom's Hardware: production cuts between October 2022 and April 2023, what they call a coordinated pivot to HBM, announcements of a DDR4 production wind-down made within a three-month span, and a failure to add capacity even as prices climbed. They say the resulting shortage pushed DRAM prices up by as much as 500% in a single year.

    They also cite tighter customer vetting introduced during the shortage, refusals to sign long-term contracts with conventional DRAM buyers, Micron's decision to close its Crucial consumer memory brand, public statements forecasting the shortage, and the companies' history in earlier price-fixing cases.

    The defendants argued that the lawsuit was a rerun of an antitrust case filed against the industry in 2018. That earlier suit was dismissed in 2020, and the Ninth Circuit upheld the dismissal in 2022, according to Tom's Hardware. The companies told the court that their choices were logical moves to maximize revenue in a period of strong demand, consistent with each firm's own self-interest, and that similar behavior is to be expected in a concentrated market where everyone faces the same pressures.

    Judge Wise was not persuaded. The companies had described themselves as competitors who watch each other closely, like hawks. The conduct alleged goes further than that, Wise wrote, likening it to "hawks flying in formation," as quoted by Tom's Hardware.

    Why the HBM shift alone was not the deciding factor

    The ruling draws a line that matters for how the industry explains itself. According to TrendForce, which cited the Korean outlet KPI News, the court partly accepted the companies' argument that moving production to HBM was not on its own enough to infer collusion, given how much more profitable HBM was at the time.

    The court weighed other alleged conduct alongside it. TrendForce said that included long-term HBM supply contracts, Samsung's and SK Hynix's refusals to sign long-term agreements with major conventional DRAM customers, and Micron's exit from Crucial. On DDR4, the companies said they had each independently decided to move to DDR5. The court noted that all three announced their exits in the same quarter while DDR4 was still widely used, TrendForce reported. Allegations that the companies introduced nearly identical customer screening questions in January 2026 added to the inference, according to the same report.

    None of the three companies has been found liable, and the complaint does not specify the damages sought, TrendForce said.

    What happens next for the memory makers

    The defendants must respond to the complaint by Dec. 7, according to both reports. TrendForce, citing Global Economic News, said an initial case management conference is scheduled for Jan. 12, 2027, to set the next steps and the scope of discovery.

    That discovery phase is where the exposure could grow. TrendForce, citing the Korean news agency NewsPim, said the companies could be required to produce internal emails, management meeting records, customer allocation criteria and documents behind capacity investment decisions. The same report said the case could give PC, smartphone and server makers more leverage to press for long-term supply agreements and larger volume commitments for conventional DRAM, though industry observers expect little immediate financial impact because U.S. antitrust cases can take years.

    The timing is awkward for the sector. In court, the memory makers have argued that their supply decisions were independent responses to AI-era demand rather than a strategy agreed among rivals. Their plans for capacity, contract terms and allocation in 2027 will now be made with a federal court watching. The next fixed date is Dec. 7, when Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron file their answers.

    Sources

    1. Tom's Hardware: Judge denies motion to dismiss DRAM price-fixing lawsuit against Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix (Nov. 15, 2026)
    2. TrendForce: U.S. Judge Rejects Samsung, SK hynix, Micron's DRAM Price-Fixing Dismissal Bid, Citing Plausible Collusion (Nov. 16, 2026)
    3. Tom's Hardware: Samsung, SK hynix, and Micron sued over alleged DRAM price fixing amid record memory costs (June 29, 2026)
    4. U.S. District Court, Northern District of California (via PacerMonitor): Garciaguirre et al v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. et al (5:26-cv-06345), docket (Nov. 14, 2026)
    5. MLex: Samsung, SK Hynix, Micron move to dismiss US DRAM price-fixing claims (Sept. 3, 2026)

    Capital Times Staff

    Capital Times newsroom, Hong Kong, Singapore and Jakarta

    Capital Times covers markets, business and economies across Asia.

    newsroom@capitaltimes.asia

    Our standards: Capital Times reports under the principles set out in our Editorial Standards and Ethics Policy. Spotted an error? Report it to our editors.

    Markets Data

    Hong Kong OpenShanghai OpenTokyo OpenSeoul OpenSingapore OpenJakarta LunchSydney ClosedMumbai Open