Markets
    GuideGuide

    Scam Losses at Singapore and Hong Kong Banks: Who Repays Under the SRF and HKMA Rules

    Singapore runs a fixed payout waterfall for phishing losses. Hong Kong judges each case. Here is how each system works, with worked examples.

    Share on X LinkedIn WhatsApp
    A bank ATM
    A bank ATM. Photo: Per Ivar Lindekrantz via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

    What to know

    • Singapore's Shared Responsibility Framework, in force since Dec. 16, 2024, makes a bank repay a phishing loss in full if it breached any of its duties, such as a 12-hour cooling-off period.
    • The Singapore framework excludes malware scams and payments victims authorize themselves, such as in investment or romance scams.
    • In Hong Kong, customers are not liable for unauthorized transactions unless they acted fraudulently or with gross negligence, while losses from authorized payment scams are assessed case by case.

    A bank customer in Singapore who loses savings to a phishing scam has a written set of rules that decides who pays. A customer in Hong Kong who is tricked into sending money is in a greyer place. Singapore's Shared Responsibility Framework (SRF), in force since Dec. 16, 2024, sets out duties for banks and telecom operators and repays the victim in full if either one breached them. Hong Kong separates hacked accounts from payments the customer approved, and judges the second kind case by case.

    The difference matters for anyone who banks in both cities. Below is how each system works, what it leaves out and what to do in the first hours after a scam.

    How Singapore's Shared Responsibility Framework Works

    The SRF applies to full banks, to payment firms that issue protected accounts and to major e-wallet providers, and to mobile network operators, according to a January 2025 briefing by law firm A&O Shearman. It covers individuals, not companies.

    The trigger is narrow. It covers phishing in which a victim clicks a link, lands on a fake website or app that impersonates a real business or government body, enters login details, and the scammer then makes transactions the victim did not authorize, according to DBS Bank's SRF page and a Reed Smith client alert.

    Banks owe five duties under the framework, according to DBS and the two law firm summaries:

    • A 12-hour cooling-off period after a digital security token is activated or a new device logs in. During that window, high-risk actions such as adding a payee, raising transfer limits or changing contact details are blocked.
    • Real-time alerts for those activations and high-risk actions.
    • Real-time notifications for every outgoing transaction.
    • A 24-hour reporting channel and a self-service "kill switch" that freezes access to the account. DBS calls its version the Safety Switch.
    • Real-time fraud surveillance for rapid drains, which took effect on June 16, 2025, after a six-month transition.

    Reed Smith said the surveillance duty applies where an account held S$50,000 or more just before the unauthorized transaction and more than half of that balance left within 24 hours. DBS warns that the checks can delay some transfers by up to 24 hours.

    Telecom operators must deliver SMS messages with a sender name only through authorized aggregators, block those that do not come through them, and filter texts containing known malicious links.

    Losses follow a waterfall. If the bank breached any duty, it repays the loss in full. If the bank complied but the telco breached its duties, the telco pays. If both complied, the customer bears the loss under the SRF but can take the case to the Financial Industry Disputes Resolution Centre (FIDReC) or the courts. A&O Shearman said there is no liability cap.

    Claims, Deadlines and What the SRF Leaves Out

    The bank is the first point of contact. A&O Shearman said customers should report no later than 30 calendar days after the bank's alerts and supply a police report and message trails within three calendar days of notifying the bank. Investigations must finish within 21 business days for straightforward cases and 45 for complex ones, according to both law firms.

    The exclusions are wide. Malware scams fall outside the SRF, as do payments victims make themselves in investment or romance scams, and credentials handed over by phone, text or in person, A&O Shearman said. Those cases fall back on each bank's own handling and on FIDReC.

    Three worked examples show how the rules apply:

    • Cooling-off breach. A customer enters her login on a fake parcel-delivery site. Two hours later the scammer logs in on a new phone, adds a payee and sends S$20,000. Adding a payee inside the 12-hour window should have been blocked. If the bank allowed it, the bank repays the full S$20,000.
    • Rapid drain. An account holds S$80,000 and a scammer moves S$50,000 out in a day, or 62.5% of the balance. That meets the drain test Reed Smith describes. If the bank and the telco both met every duty, the loss stays with the customer under the SRF, and FIDReC remains open.
    • Authorized transfer. A customer wires S$30,000 to a fake investment platform himself. The SRF does not apply.

    Hong Kong: Two Kinds of Scam, Two Standards

    Hong Kong has no equivalent waterfall. For unauthorized transactions, such as transfers from a hacked account, the HKMA said customers are not liable under the Code of Banking Practice unless they acted fraudulently or with gross negligence.

    Authorized payment scams are different. The HKMA's deputy chief executive, Arthur Yuen, wrote in September 2025 that customers are primarily responsible for checking payments before approving them, while banks are expected to run effective monitoring and warnings. He gave two examples. A bank that flagged a likely scam but did not follow HKMA guidance and failed to warn the customer bears a degree of responsibility. A customer who goes ahead after repeated warnings bears the loss.

    On Sept. 26, 2025, the HKMA consulted banks on a framework for these claims. It covers individual customers, authorized payments and transfers through Hong Kong bank accounts, and sets no fixed split between bank and customer, The Standard reported. The customer's circumstances also count; Yuen gave an elderly victim as an example. The Standard said the HKMA will not order banks to pay, and dissatisfied customers can lodge a complaint with their bank. The framework does not expect banks to catch every scam, only to show reasonable, risk-based measures, the newspaper said. The South China Morning Post reported that the consultation went to retail banks.

    The banking industry sent its feedback on Dec. 1, 2025, and the HKMA said it was studying the submissions, Sing Tao Headline reported. Capital Times could not confirm whether a final version has been issued since, so readers should check the HKMA website. Sing Tao, citing HKMA data, said scam-related complaints to the regulator fell to 828 in 2024 from 1,201 in 2023; 536 involved unauthorized transactions and 292 authorized payment scams.

    Hong Kong's main preventive tool is Money Safe. Customers choose an amount of deposits that cannot be moved through any channel; reducing it requires a visit to a branch, and banks process the request within three working days, The Standard reported. An HKMA presentation said all retail banks were due to offer it by the end of 2025.

    For more on how other markets assign liability, see Capital Times' report on South Korea's phishing liability rules and our editorial on who should bear digital fraud losses.

    The practical steps are the same in both cities: use the bank's kill switch or hotline at once, report to the police, keep every message and screenshot, and file the claim in writing. In Singapore, the 30-day reporting window is the deadline to note.

    This guide is general information, not financial or legal advice.

    Sources

    1. Hong Kong Monetary Authority: Who Bears the Responsibility for Scam Losses? (Sept. 26, 2025)
    2. Hong Kong Monetary Authority: Regulatory Update by HKMA, HKIB Annual Banking Conference (Sept. 26, 2025)
    3. DBS Bank: About Shared Responsibility Framework (SRF) (Nov. 19, 2026)
    4. A&O Shearman via Mondaq: Combatting payment account fraud: Singapore's Shared Responsibility Framework (Jan. 15, 2025)
    5. Reed Smith: Singapore to implement Shared Responsibility Framework for phishing scams (Nov. 1, 2024)
    6. WongPartnership: Proposed enhancements to the E-Payments User Protection Guidelines and Shared Responsibility Framework (Oct. 25, 2023)
    7. The Standard: HKMA issues guidelines on authorized payment fraud claims (Sept. 26, 2025)
    8. South China Morning Post: Hong Kong regulator, banks go back and forth on who pays scam loss claims (Sept. 26, 2025)
    9. Sing Tao Headline: 金管局諮詢騙案索償 銀行業界反應大 關注難釐清責任 憂機制被詐騙者濫用 (Dec. 22, 2025)
    10. The Standard: Money Safe service will help prevent banking fraud (Dec. 4, 2024)

    Capital Times Staff

    Capital Times newsroom, Hong Kong, Singapore and Jakarta

    Capital Times covers markets, business and economies across Asia.

    newsroom@capitaltimes.asia

    Our standards: Capital Times reports under the principles set out in our Editorial Standards and Ethics Policy. Spotted an error? Report it to our editors.

    Markets Data

    Hong Kong ClosedShanghai ClosedTokyo ClosedSeoul ClosedSingapore ClosedJakarta ClosedSydney ClosedMumbai Closed