Japan's GPIF Trails 3 Mutual Aid Pension Funds Since 2020 as Talk of a Home Shift Fades
A Daiwa Institute of Research review puts the $2 trillion fund's cumulative return at 105% against 117% to 119% for two of its peers, and says a near-term portfolio overhaul now looks unlikely.

What to know
- GPIF's cumulative return from fiscal 2020 through September 2026 was 105.05%, the lowest of four funds that manage Japan's employee pension reserves, according to Daiwa Institute of Research.
- All four of GPIF's asset classes sat near their 25% targets at end-September, and Daiwa said the chance of a near-term portfolio revision has receded considerably.
- Daiwa estimated that a minus 10% quarter would now cost GPIF more than 30 trillion yen, and pointed to Korea's National Pension Service as a warning on home bias.
TOKYO
Japan's Government Pension Investment Fund has earned less than each of the three public servant and private school pension funds that invest under the same rules, with a cumulative return of 105.05% from fiscal 2020 through September, according to a Nov. 10 report by Daiwa Institute of Research. The same report concluded that the chance of GPIF rewriting its model portfolio any time soon has receded considerably, after months of market talk that the government wanted more of the fund's money at home.
The two findings matter to anyone with exposure to Japanese stocks and bonds, and to Japanese workers whose future employee pension benefits the fund helps finance. GPIF held 314.4 trillion yen at the end of September, according to Jiji Press, and The Edge Malaysia has described it as one of the world's largest public pension investors. A tilt of even a few percentage points between domestic and foreign assets would move trillions of yen across the yen, Japanese government bonds and the Tokyo stock market.
How GPIF compares with its peers
Since Japan merged its employee pension systems, GPIF and three mutual aid associations manage employee pension reserves under one shared set of investment guidelines. That makes them a rare like-for-like comparison. Daiwa's table, compiled from each fund's disclosures, ranks them for every fiscal year since 2020.
The Promotion and Mutual Aid Corporation for Private Schools of Japan came first, with a cumulative 118.56%. The Federation of National Public Service Personnel Mutual Aid Associations followed at 117.25%, then the Pension Fund Association for Local Government Officials at 106.42%. GPIF was last at 105.05%.
The gap held this year. In the April-September half, GPIF returned 6.42%, a figure confirmed in the fund's own quarterly report, while the three peers returned between 6.73% and 7.89%, Daiwa said. GPIF did outperform two of them in the July-September quarter, ranking second behind the national civil servants' fund.
Kenji Shiomura, a Daiwa fellow and the report's author, attributed the shortfall mainly to changes in GPIF's investment philosophy and style since its fourth medium-term plan began in fiscal 2020, a case he said he made in earlier reports in July and August. He wrote that large headline gains, such as the 41.4 trillion yen GPIF earned in fiscal 2025, can hide weaknesses, which makes a strong period the right time to address them.
Why a domestic shift now looks less likely
Speculation about a change in GPIF's 25% split among domestic bonds, foreign bonds, domestic stocks and foreign stocks built through the summer. Daiwa traced it to Finance Minister Katayama, who said after a cabinet meeting on July 10 that he wanted to find ways to encourage pension funds, including GPIF, to invest more in Japanese financial assets. The Edge Malaysia reported that Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi's suggestion in July that GPIF could buy more domestic assets, and a surprise management meeting in August, fueled the expectations.
The September numbers showed no movement. GPIF's quarterly report put domestic bonds at 26.49%, domestic equities at 24.80%, foreign equities at 24.67% and foreign bonds at 24.05%. Those figures include about 5.4 trillion yen of reserves in the government's pension special account, which counts as domestic bonds. Stripping that out, Daiwa calculated that every asset class sat between 24.46% and 25.23%, a deviation it called within the margin of error. GPIF's report shows permitted bands of plus or minus 6 percentage points for domestic bonds, domestic equities and foreign equities, and 5 points for foreign bonds.
"It appears GPIF is barely making use of the permitted deviation ranges," Koji Okuda, an executive researcher at Daiichi Life Research Institute, said, according to The Edge Malaysia. He saw no sign of a change to the model portfolio.
Daiwa added two more pieces of evidence. It cited an Oct. 6 Bloomberg article in which a GPIF spokesperson said the August meeting received the results of an annual portfolio review and that current conditions did not differ greatly from what the portfolio assumes. And the published agendas for the board's Sept. 28 and Oct. 23 meetings showed no further portfolio item after the August session.
The Korean warning
The report then turned to Seoul. Korea's National Pension Service paused automatic rebalancing of domestic stocks on Jan. 26 and on May 28 lifted its 2026 target for Korean equities to 20.8% from 14.9%, Daiwa said. Korean stocks later fell sharply. Citing estimates from data provider FnGuide, the report said the value of NPS stakes in 287 listed companies where it owns at least 5% dropped by about 182 trillion won between the end of June and Oct. 15. Capital Times has argued that Korea's fund should keep 20.8% as a ceiling.
Shiomura described a "whale in a pond" problem. Home investment avoids currency risk and supports the local economy, he wrote, but a fund that dominates its own market can find rebalancing hard, which may conflict with members' interests.
GPIF is not immune to swings on its current scale. It lost 5.25 trillion yen, or 1.65%, in the July-September quarter, its first loss in six quarters, as foreign bonds fell 6.52% and the dollar dropped more than 3% against the yen, according to GPIF and Asia Asset Management. Japanese stocks returned 3.71%, the only gaining asset class. Tokyo shares have since been volatile, after the Nikkei 225 fell 5.2% in October.
Daiwa calculated that a repeat of GPIF's worst quarter since 2008, the minus 10.71% recorded in January-March 2020, would today mean a paper loss of more than 30 trillion yen in a single quarter. Shiomura urged readers to judge the fund by its rate of return rather than the yen amount, and to separate market-driven losses from underperformance caused by GPIF's own choices.
This article is general information, not financial advice.
Sources
- Daiwa Institute of Research: GPIFの運用状況と韓国国民年金からの学び (Nov. 10, 2026)
- Government Pension Investment Fund: Investment results for 2Q of fiscal 2026 (update report) (Nov. 6, 2026)
- The Edge Malaysia: Japan's GPIF fund keeps quarterly asset allocation little changed (Nov. 6, 2026)
- Nippon.com (Jiji Press): Japan's Public Pension Fund Logs 5.2-T.-Yen Loss in 3rd Quarter (Nov. 6, 2026)
- Asia Asset Management: GPIF reports investment loss in second fiscal quarter (Nov. 10, 2026)
Our standards: Capital Times reports under the principles set out in our Editorial Standards and Ethics Policy. Spotted an error? Report it to our editors.







