Hedged vs Unhedged ETFs: Why a Yen-Hedged Japan Fund Gained 110% to Its Twin's 34%
Two iShares funds own the same Japanese stocks. One strips out the yen. How currency hedging works, what it costs, and which home currency it actually protects.

What to know
- BlackRock's yen-hedged iShares MSCI Japan USD Hedged UCITS ETF returned about 110% over 2022 to 2025, against about 34% for its unhedged twin, by Capital Times' calculation from iShares data.
- The hedged fund charges a 0.64% total expense ratio, against 0.12% for the unhedged iShares MSCI Japan UCITS ETF, according to iShares.
- With the Fed's range at 3.75% to 4% and the Bank of Japan's rate at about 1.25%, hedging yen into dollars currently earns roughly the gap, while hedging dollars into yen costs it.
Two exchange-traded funds run by BlackRock in Ireland hold the same 167 Japanese companies. One, the iShares MSCI Japan UCITS ETF, leaves its yen exposure alone. The other, the iShares MSCI Japan USD Hedged UCITS ETF, uses currency contracts to strip the yen out. From 2022 through 2025, the hedged fund roughly doubled while the unhedged one gained about a third, according to calendar-year returns published by iShares.
That gap had nothing to do with stock picking. It came from the yen, and from a choice many investors in Hong Kong, Singapore and Jakarta make without noticing when they pick a share class. This guide explains how hedging works, what it costs and when it has failed to pay.
How a currency-hedged ETF works
An unhedged fund that owns Japanese shares gives a dollar-based investor two returns at once: the change in share prices in yen, and the change in the yen against the dollar. A hedged fund tries to keep only the first.
It does this with forward contracts, agreements to exchange currencies at a set rate on a future date. If the yen weakens, the forwards gain enough to offset the lost value of the shares when converted into dollars. If the yen strengthens, the forwards lose and cancel the currency gain. The result, as justETF puts it, is roughly the return of the local stock market, though the hedge is never perfect.
The iShares hedged Japan fund resets its hedge monthly, its product page says. Between resets the hedge can drift. justETF gives the example of a contract sized for US$10 million when the holdings have risen to US$12 million, leaving part of the portfolio exposed until the next roll.
The track record: iShares Japan, hedged and unhedged
The two funds' annual returns in US dollars, from iShares, show how large the currency effect can be.
In 2022 the unhedged fund lost 17.1%, while the hedged version lost 2.7%. In 2023 the hedged fund returned 34.5% against 19.7%, and in 2024 it returned 25.6% against 8.2%. In 2025 the gap narrowed to 27.7% against 24.5%.
Compounded, US$10,000 put into the hedged fund at the start of 2022 would have grown to about US$20,990 by the end of 2025. The same sum in the unhedged fund would have reached about US$13,370, by Capital Times' calculation from those figures. The pattern has held this year: the hedged fund was up 15.87% as of Nov. 17 and the unhedged one 12.02% as of Nov. 9, the latest dates shown on their iShares pages. MSCI said in September that its yen-hedged Japan index had outperformed the unhedged version by about 470 basis points through August.
Hedging does not always win. In 2020 the unhedged fund returned 13.8% against 9.0% for the hedged one, and over 2016 to 2019 US$10,000 would have grown to about US$12,940 unhedged versus about US$12,250 hedged. When the yen strengthens, the hedge gives that gain away.
What hedging costs, and who pays
There are two costs. The first is the fee. The hedged fund charges a total expense ratio of 0.64% a year, against 0.12% for the unhedged one, according to iShares. On US$10,000 that is US$64 a year versus US$12. justETF says many hedged ETFs cost 0.1 to 0.3 percentage points a year more than their unhedged versions, so the Japan pair sits at the expensive end.
The second cost, or benefit, is the interest-rate gap between the two currencies, which is built into forward prices. When the investor's hedged-to currency pays a higher interest rate than the currency being hedged away, the hedge adds roughly that difference to returns. When it pays less, the hedge subtracts it.
Right now the gap is wide. The Federal Reserve held its target range at 3.75% to 4% on Oct. 28, and the Bank of Japan kept its overnight call rate target at around 1.25% on Oct. 30. A dollar-based investor hedging yen therefore picks up roughly 2.5 to 2.75 percentage points a year before costs, the same spread that drives the yen carry trade.
A Japanese investor hedging US assets back into yen faces the mirror image. FTSE Russell's head of fixed income, currency and commodities research, Robin Marshall, wrote this month that hedged 10-year Treasury yields have been below 10-year Japanese government bond yields since 2022. In FTSE Russell's data, its world government bond index excluding Japan returned 7.06% a year from 2022 to 2026 for yen-based investors who did not hedge, and minus 4.68% a year for those who hedged fully.
Which home currency does the hedge protect?
This is the question Asian investors most often skip. The iShares fund hedges yen back to US dollars, not to Hong Kong dollars, Singapore dollars or rupiah.
For a Hong Kong investor that is close to a full hedge. The Hong Kong Monetary Authority stands ready to sell Hong Kong dollars at HK$7.75 per US dollar and buy them at HK$7.85, which keeps the local currency in a narrow band against the dollar.
For a Singapore or Indonesian investor, a dollar-hedged fund swaps yen risk for dollar risk. A Singaporean who buys it still gains or loses as the Singapore dollar moves against the US dollar, and an Indonesian holder is still exposed to the rupiah. Some fund ranges offer share classes hedged to other currencies; the iShares page notes that all of the fund's hedged share classes use derivatives, which can carry spill-over risk between classes.
Three checks before choosing:
- Read the index name. "MSCI Japan 100% Hedged to USD" tells you both what is hedged and into what.
- Compare fees and fund size. The hedged Japan fund held about US$583 million on Nov. 17, against about US$4.72 billion for the unhedged one on Nov. 9, iShares data show.
- Check the domicile and listing. Both funds are domiciled in Ireland; our guide to US-listed and Irish ETFs covers how domicile affects dividend tax.
The hedging arithmetic will move with the next Fed and Bank of Japan decisions, since every change in the rate gap flows into forward prices. One practical date is closer: BlackRock says one listing line of the hedged Japan fund will be delisted on Dec. 15, so holders should confirm which exchange and ticker they own.
This article is general information, not financial advice.
Sources
- iShares by BlackRock: iShares MSCI Japan USD Hedged UCITS ETF (Acc) (Nov. 17, 2026)
- iShares by BlackRock: iShares MSCI Japan UCITS ETF USD (Dist) (Nov. 17, 2026)
- MSCI: Japan's rally looked different in dollars (Sept. 9, 2026)
- FTSE Russell (LSEG): A yen to carry or time to hedge? (Nov. 3, 2026)
- justETF: How currency-hedged ETFs protect you from currency risk (May 27, 2019)
- Federal Reserve: Federal Reserve issues FOMC statement (Oct. 28, 2026)
- Bank of Japan: Statement on Monetary Policy (Oct. 30, 2026)
- Hong Kong Monetary Authority: How does the Linked Exchange Rate System work?
Our standards: Capital Times reports under the principles set out in our Editorial Standards and Ethics Policy. Spotted an error? Report it to our editors.







