Markets
    CopperAnalysis

    Copper Fee Talks Open in Shanghai as Poll Sees 2027 Benchmark at Minus $50 to $150

    Miners and Chinese smelters meet this week to set next year's processing fees, with spot charges already near minus $250 a ton and China's cathode output slipping.

    Share on X LinkedIn WhatsApp
    The entrance to a copper smelter in Alaverdi, Armenia
    A copper smelter in Alaverdi, Armenia. Photo: Gardmanahay via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

    What to know

    • In a Reuters poll of 35 smelters, miners, traders and analysts published Nov. 13, 21 expected a negative fixed 2027 copper benchmark, with forecasts from minus $50 to minus $150 a ton.
    • Spot treatment charges fell to minus $247.20 a ton on Nov. 6, Reuters reported, while Antofagasta sold Centinela concentrate at minus $310 a ton in an October tender, according to sources cited by Reuters.
    • China's copper cathode output fell 3.03% from September to 1.0867 million tons in October, according to Shanghai Metals Market, as 11 smelters carried out maintenance.

    HONG KONG

    Copper miners and Chinese smelters are meeting in Shanghai this week to haggle over next year's processing fees, and for the first time most of the industry expects the benchmark to be set below zero. In a Reuters poll of 35 smelters, miners, traders and analysts published on Friday, 21 said they expected a negative fixed treatment and refining charge for 2027, with forecasts ranging from minus $50 to minus $150 a metric ton.

    The number matters well beyond the negotiating room. The annual settlement between a major miner, in recent years Chile's Antofagasta, and Chinese smelters sets the reference price for long-term concentrate contracts across Asia. A negative figure means smelters pay miners to process their ore, a reversal of how the business has worked for decades. That shifts money from refiners toward the mining companies that sell them ore.

    The talks coincide with the World Copper Conference Asia in Shanghai, which Reuters said the industry would attend this week. James Whelan wrote in his weekly column for Small Caps on Monday that the gathering, known in the trade as CESCO Week, had opened that day.

    From $80 to below zero

    Treatment and refining charges, or TC/RCs, were traditionally a fee miners paid smelters to turn concentrate, or partially processed copper ore, into refined metal. The benchmark has collapsed as mine supply failed to keep up with new smelting capacity. Whelan put the annual figure at $80 a ton for 2024, $21.25 for 2025 and zero for 2026. The Deep Dive, a Canadian mining news site, also reported the 2026 benchmark at $0 and the 2025 level at $21.25.

    The spot market has gone much further. Spot charges, negative since early 2025, fell again to minus $247.20 a ton on Nov. 6, Reuters reported. In October, Antofagasta was paid $310 a ton by smelters to take 10,000 tons of concentrate from its Centinela mine for November shipment, and sold 40,000 tons from Los Pelambres spread over 2027 in the minus $330s, according to two sources cited by Reuters. Canada's Teck Resources sold material from its Highland Valley mine in the minus $370s, Reuters said, citing a second and a third source.

    In its October report on the Antofagasta tenders, Reuters traced the shortage to a run of mine disruptions, beginning with the shutdown of First Quantum's Cobre Panama mine in late 2023 and most recently a deadly landslide at Codelco's El Teniente mine in Chile. On the other side of the ledger, China's copper smelting capacity is estimated at 13 million to 14 million tons this year, up more than 70% over a decade, according to that report.

    Even a deal at the poll's range would leave a gap of roughly $100 to $200 a ton against spot levels. Three of the 21 respondents who expect a negative price said they also expect fewer cargoes to trade at the benchmark. Seven respondents thought the annual system would be dismantled in favor of spot pricing, and seven were undecided. Raghav Jain, head of copper pricing at Argus, told Reuters the benchmark could survive in 2027 as a reference point while becoming "less representative of where the wider market actually trades."

    China's smelters are already cutting

    The economics are showing up in Chinese output. China produced 1.0867 million tons of copper cathode in October, down 3.03% from September and 0.45% from a year earlier, according to Shanghai Metals Market (SMM). The data provider said 11 smelters were under maintenance during the month, removing 103,200 tons of output, the largest maintenance impact since it began collecting the data.

    SMM estimated that smelters buying spot concentrate lost 5,714.80 yuan a ton in October, about 1,581.51 yuan more than in September. It expects November output to slip a further 0.42% to 1.0821 million tons and said losses could widen to around 6,500 yuan a ton as sulfuric acid prices fall. Acid is a by-product that has helped smelters absorb negative fees. Capital Times reported last week that China's copper concentrate imports fell 11% in October.

    Chinese smelters, backed by their state-supported industry association, have resisted negative term prices, Reuters reported. Whelan, citing Ivanhoe Mines founder Robert Friedland, wrote that the gap between what miners and smelters want for 2027 is the widest on record, and that Friedland says Chinese smelters have signaled they would accept a "sizeable" negative benchmark. Friedland had warned before London Metal Exchange Week in October that the two sides might fail to agree a 2027 benchmark at all, The Deep Dive reported.

    Who wins and who loses

    A negative benchmark acts like a bonus for miners that sell concentrate, on top of the copper price. The pressure falls hardest on custom smelters outside China, which lack the scale and by-product income of the largest Chinese plants. Whelan pointed to Glencore's Mount Isa smelter and Townsville refinery in Australia, which needed a government rescue of A$600 million in October 2025 to keep running until the end of 2028.

    The benchmark has already been chipped away. In July, Antofagasta agreed spot-indexed sales with some Chinese smelters, Whelan wrote. Glencore Chief Executive Gary Nagle said on an earnings call in October that spot markets were taking a larger role across commodities, noting the "chrome benchmark has fallen away," Reuters reported. Iron ore made the same move to spot pricing in 2010.

    For Asian investors, the settlement figure feeds directly into the margins of listed smelters and the realized prices of concentrate producers. Capital Times has also covered London copper stocks at a four-month high. Any agreement reached in Shanghai this week would set terms for 2027 term cargoes, and SMM's November production figures will show how many Chinese smelters have chosen to cut rather than pay for ore.

    Sources

    1. Reuters via Mining.com.au: Copper benchmark rocked by miner-smelter tug-of-war (Nov. 13, 2026)
    2. Small Caps: The Whelan Wrap: When benchmarks break (Nov. 16, 2026)
    3. Reuters via Kitco: Antofagasta nets its highest ever copper treatment charges in auction, sources say (Oct. 16, 2026)
    4. Shanghai Metals Market (SMM): China's Copper Cathode Output Drops in October, Raw Material Supply Tightens (Oct. 31, 2026)
    5. The Deep Dive: Copper Miners and Smelters May Fail to Agree on 2027 Benchmark as Fees Stay Negative, Friedland Warns (Oct. 12, 2026)

    Capital Times Staff

    Capital Times newsroom, Hong Kong, Singapore and Jakarta

    Capital Times covers markets, business and economies across Asia.

    newsroom@capitaltimes.asia

    Our standards: Capital Times reports under the principles set out in our Editorial Standards and Ethics Policy. Spotted an error? Report it to our editors.

    Markets Data

    Hong Kong ClosedShanghai ClosedTokyo ClosedSeoul ClosedSingapore ClosedJakarta ClosedSydney ClosedMumbai Closed