Korea Zinc Wins Appeal on Hyundai Share Sale a Day After Court Voids Its 2025 AGM Votes
A Seoul court cancelled board votes taken while Young Poong was barred from voting. An appeals court then upheld a 2023 share sale to a Hyundai unit.

What to know
- The Seoul Central District Court on Nov. 12 cancelled resolutions from Korea Zinc's March 2025 meeting, including a 19-seat board cap and the election of six directors aligned with Chairman Choi Yun-beom.
- A day later the Seoul High Court reversed a lower ruling and upheld Korea Zinc's 2023 sale of 1,045,430 new shares, about 5% of the company, to Hyundai Motor Group affiliate HMG Global.
- Nine of Korea Zinc's 19 directors, six from Choi's side and three from the Young Poong-MBK alliance, finish their terms on March 28, 2027.
SEOUL
Two Seoul courts handed down opposing decisions in the fight for control of Korea Zinc in the space of two days last week, leaving neither Chairman Choi Yun-beom nor the alliance of Young Poong Corp. and MBK Partners with a clean win heading into a 2027 shareholder vote.
On Thursday, the Seoul Central District Court cancelled resolutions passed at Korea Zinc's March 2025 annual meeting, at which Young Poong had been barred from voting. On Friday, the Seoul High Court reversed a lower-court ruling and upheld Korea Zinc's 2023 sale of 1,045,430 new shares to HMG Global, an overseas affiliate of Hyundai Motor Group, according to Yonhap News Agency. That stake gave the Hyundai side about 5% of Korea Zinc, and Korea Economic TV described keeping it as protecting a key defense for the chairman.
For investors in Asia, the case is a test of how far South Korean boards can go in responding to a takeover bid backed by private equity. Korea Zinc is the world's largest refined zinc smelter, Yonhap said, and Young Poong and MBK have voted together since signing an agreement in September 2024 to win control of the company.
Court Voids the 2025 Korea Zinc Meeting
The first ruling came from a civil panel of the Seoul Central District Court presided over by Judge Ko Seung-il. It sided with Young Poong and MBK and cancelled every resolution at issue, including changes to the articles of incorporation and the election of directors and audit committee members, The Korea Economic Daily (Hankyung) and BusinessKorea reported.
The dispute goes back to the eve of that March 2025 meeting. Choi's side moved a 10.3% holding in Young Poong, held by an Australian unit of Korea Zinc, to another Australian subsidiary, Sun Metals Holdings, through a dividend paid in kind, Hankyung reported. Under South Korea's Commercial Act, if one company owns more than a tenth of another, the second company cannot vote its shares in the first. The new cross-holding stripped Young Poong of the votes attached to its roughly 25.4% stake in Korea Zinc, according to Hankyung.
The court said Korea Zinc could not invoke the cross-shareholding rules to curb existing shareholders' voting rights as a means of defending management control, Yonhap reported. The cancelled resolutions include a cap of 19 board seats and the election of six directors aligned with Choi, among them Chief Executive Park Ki-deok, Hankyung said.
Korea Zinc said it would appeal immediately. In a statement carried by Yonhap, it said the ruling ran against existing Supreme Court precedent and against the top court's decision in an earlier injunction case over the same vote. Hankyung reported that the Supreme Court finally rejected that injunction request in April.
Young Poong and MBK called on Choi to apologize to shareholders. They also said 57 billion won of company money had been used to defend his control, according to BusinessKorea.
Appeals Court Upholds Hyundai Share Sale
Friday's ruling went the other way. A civil division of the Seoul High Court dismissed Young Poong's suit seeking to void the August 2023 share issue to HMG Global, finding that it was done within the range needed to meet the company's management goals, Yonhap reported. The issue was worth about 500 billion won, according to Korea Economic TV.
Korea Zinc's articles allow new shares to be issued to an outside party when the company needs to do so for a foreign joint venture. In June 2025, the lower court ruled that HMG Global did not qualify as such a joint venture and sided with Young Poong. The appeals court did not explain its reasoning in the courtroom, Yonhap said. The suit, filed in March 2024, set off the open dispute between Korea Zinc and Young Poong, Yonhap said.
Korea Zinc said the ruling confirmed that the share sale was a legitimate business decision. Young Poong said it deeply regretted the outcome and would consider further legal action once it received the written judgment, which Yonhap took to mean a possible appeal to the Supreme Court.
Korea Economic TV said keeping the Hyundai stake in place also helps Choi's broader strategy of issuing new shares to friendly partners, including more than 2 trillion won of shares allocated to a joint venture formed with the U.S. government.
Board Math Before the March 2027 Meeting
The two rulings leave the board in flux. After an extraordinary meeting in September, Korea Zinc's board has 19 members: 12 on Choi's side and seven backed by Young Poong and MBK, Hankyung reported.
If Young Poong and MBK ask a court to suspend the six directors elected in 2025 and win, the balance would shift to seven against six in the alliance's favor, the newspaper said. Korea Zinc could respond with its own request to suspend directors on the other side. Because the appeal will take time, the company expects little immediate effect on its board, according to Hankyung.
The next fixed date is March 28, 2027, when the terms of nine directors end: six from Choi's side and three from the alliance, Hankyung reported. If the first ruling stands, the 19-seat cap would no longer limit how many new directors Young Poong and MBK could nominate at that meeting, Hankyung said. Both camps are expected to court institutional investors, Korea Economic TV said.
The case is one of several control contests in Korean boardrooms this year, along with the shifting stakes at Korean Air's parent Hanjin KAL. Korea Zinc's appeal of Thursday's ruling, any injunction request against the six directors, and a possible Supreme Court appeal by Young Poong are the next steps to watch before the March meeting.
Sources
- Yonhap News Agency: Korea Zinc loses court battle over curbs on Young Poong's voting rights (Nov. 12, 2026)
- Yonhap News Agency (Korean): 고려아연, 주총결의 취소 1심 패소에 "즉시 항소"…영풍은 환영 (Korea Zinc to appeal immediately; Young Poong welcomes ruling) (Nov. 12, 2026)
- The Korea Economic Daily (Hankyung): 경영권 또 흔들리나…고려아연 이사회 '격랑' (Korea Zinc board in turmoil after ruling) (Nov. 12, 2026)
- BusinessKorea: Court Voids Korea Zinc Shareholder Meeting Over Restricted Voting Rights (Nov. 12, 2026)
- Yonhap News Agency (Korean): 고려아연, '신주발행 다툼' 2심서 영풍에 승소…1심 뒤집혀(종합) (Korea Zinc wins appeal over share issuance) (Nov. 13, 2026)
- Yonhap News Agency (Korean): '신주발행 소송 패소'에 영풍 "후속 법적조치"·고려아연 "환영" (Young Poong plans further legal steps; Korea Zinc welcomes ruling) (Nov. 13, 2026)
- Korea Economic TV via Hankyung: 고려아연 하루 만에 반격…'우군 현대차' 지켰다 (Korea Zinc strikes back, keeps Hyundai as ally) (Nov. 13, 2026)
Our standards: Capital Times reports under the principles set out in our Editorial Standards and Ethics Policy. Spotted an error? Report it to our editors.







